MOT, Service & Evans Halshaw

ProjectPuma

Help Support ProjectPuma:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

si1881

Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2011
Messages
30
Location
Barnsley
So I think I made a mistake by the offer of extra Nectar Card points if you had a service and MOT done by your local Ford dealer.... Just been to collect my Puma after dropping off this morning at Evans Halshaw in Lincoln after looking at a few of the other local garages and deciding their price offer didn't seem bad by comparison. Agreed they'd MOT it first then let me know and not service if it failed unless it was a couple of 'minor' things.

Then the call 'sorry your car has failed with the lower arm bushes but it also needs some bulbs, the rear washer isn't working and the exhaust is blowing'. Me being more than a little suspicious asked for prices and was told varying things especially as the bulbs were all checked this morning before dropping off and as far as I was aware the rear washer doesn't come into the test... I was quoted approx £60 a side if the lower arm bushes would come out plus a couple of hours labour plus VAT but that 'normally the bushes don't come out so we have to fit new arms at £140+VAT each'. At this point I said don't do anything else I'll come and pick it up and get it done elsewhere - to which I was told there would be a retest fee.

Get to pick the car up to find that they then carried on and did the short service despite agreeing at booking in that if it failed not to service... so £53 for the MOT and £65 for the service which wouldn't have been to bad if didn't need the other things doing... Also no bulbs not working, just tried the rear screen wash and if you hold it for more than 3 seconds out comes water

So i'm probably already preaching to the converted but would say steer clear of Lincoln Evans Halshaw unless you can really rely on them to follow your instructions - especially as the general service was one of reluctance to speak or smile and the feeling we were interfering with their other work of the day.

On the way home took it to a local garage that does MOTs and says its a Ford specialist that I probably should have gone to initially (though MOT and service costs very similar) and now got it booked in for the bushes only as they said no problem to change and all in for £140 to 160 including VAT etc. On looking they've also said they'd probably only have reported the one side... but suppose might as well have it done now :roll:

Don't know whether to bother with paying for the 'retest' now or just get the other garage to do a complete test for ease while its in but also run the risk of them failing it on something else :?
 
Always get your tests done at the local council depot is my advice. They only fail you if the car is unroadworthy....which is what garages are supposed to do as far as I know. Unfortunately they are far too keen to 'find' a problem. The council have no reason to 'find' any problems as they don't do repairs. Might mean you have to pay for a retest if it fails but at least you know it genuinely failed. :eek:k:
 
I wouldn't of paid, would of got the police involved, they broke a verbal contract.
 
I'd get it retested at the other garage. I took mine to Ford once and decided never again. High prices, took ages to do the service, was told to come and collect at a certain time only to get there and they were still working on it. I was waiting around for like an hour!

Obviously dont take my word for it and get your hopes up but if all the things Ford found are being dealt with, then chances are theres nothing else wrong with it. Surely Ford would have picked up on every single minor problem there was just to try and squeeze more money out of you! :-(

Robbing b@stards.
 
Hate to play devil's advocate here but a lot of dealerships (mine included) offer bonuses to technicians if they 'sell' extra work and parts etc.However they've broken their contract by carrying out work on the car that you have not authorised so you could have refused to pay
 
yeah did consider making a fuss but it did need a service and they seem to have done a reasonable job (looking at service book not had oil change since Dec 09 before I got it earlier this year) - couldn't really be bothered with the hassle either this time. Won't be taking it back through choice again tho...
 
i bought a 2008 fiesta st 500 from allen ford in brentwood, is was due a service which they agreed to do in the price. however, i couldn't pick the car up until almost closing time so i had no time to check it over until i'd driven the 120 miles home. coolant was on minimum, engine oil was on minimum and the tyres pressures were dangerously low. if thats their idea of fords servicing i'd never use one of their dealers again, for anything.

i agree with the above post, take it to your local council test station or at the least a local garage that is a test station only!!!
 
Back
Top